D. A. Carson’s Exegetical Fallacies is a must-read for Bible interpreters. I do not use that classification lightly. There is a reason why this book is regularly assigned by seminary professors, recommended by many Bible teachers, and is now in its third edition.
Christian scholars, pastors, and non-vocational believers alike have benefited greatly from Carson’s taxonomy of the various errors to which Bible interpreters often and easily fall prey. By making us aware of common yet misguided exegetical moves, Carson helps guard Bible teachers from falling into those mistakes as they expound the text of God’s Word. The blessing of such instruction for the teacher and student is incalculable.
My aim in this article, however, is not to engage in detail or even outline Carson’s book. Others have done this, and I would point you to their work (see here, and here). Rather, I want to use Exegetical Fallacies to make one basic plea: Let’s all slow down.
I first read Exegetical Fallacies in seminary (second edition). I recently listened to an audio version of the book (also the second edition). My second venture through the book left me with one dominant and lasting impression: I need to exercise great care and caution as I study God’s Word and teach it to others.
I recognize this is an obvious conclusion that does not shed much insight on anything. But my point is this article is not to note anything new, but to stir us up by way of reminder.
What Carson’s book should do is prompt us, at least, to remember that rightly interpreting a passage and giving appropriate attention to all the necessary elements of a sound exegetical method requires both time and patience. Weighing possible word meanings, syntactical relationships between various parts of a sentence, logical connections between verses and paragraphs, a passage’s immediate and broader contexts, the potential insights from background information, how our interpretation fits within the author’s larger corpus and the Bible as a whole, potential problems that arise with our interpretation and how to plausibly solve them, and how our passage sits within the greater redemptive storyline of the Bible cannot be done in a rushed, harried environment.
Getting to the true meaning of Scripture simply takes time. There are no shortcuts.
The Gift of Inefficiency
Or maybe there are. At least that’s what we are tempted to believe with the dawn of another promising form of technology.
Whatever your current personal or institutional policies are for the use of A.I., there is no disputing that one aim of this powerful tool is to make our daily work more efficient. Efficiency as such is not immoral or unethical, and we can all thank God for providing us with technologies that enable us to garner the same or better results in less time.
But some things in life are not enhanced when they are made more efficient. I doubt my wife and I would experience greater satisfaction in our relationship if we found a way to speed up date night. Actually, we apply efficiency to other tasks (clothes in the washing machine, dishes in the dishwasher, bills on auto-pay) so that we can (ideally) spend more time together without the need to rush to the next task.
Granted, it is often the case that we find ourselves still rushed despite the abundance of tools we have at hand to accomplish our tasks with greater ease and speed. The more time we have, the more likely we are to fill that time. But our failure to rightly use our time is no argument against the truth that certain aspects of our existence thrive on inefficiency.
I believe biblical study is one aspect of our walk with God that we should be wary of making more efficient.
Helpful and Unhelpful Inefficiency
I recognize that the line between good and unhelpful efficiency is a little blurry. For example, I have no problem using Accordance Bible software to help me in the biblical languages or to make it easier to locate where certain words are used throughout the Bible. I’ve known others, however, who are repulsed by this idea and always use physical copies of lexicons, exegetical tools, and concordances for their research.
But, even though I love Accordance, I rarely use digital exegetical guides (like SIL on Accordance) because I want think through the issues of the text for myself before I go to commentaries and other tools. Others are happy to use such tools often for their work and see no problem with them.
I also do not like having a load of digital resources on my computer (like Logos) because I prefer the built-in slowness of using the corresponding physical copies. Again, other men I highly respect use these resources and have been wonderfully fruitful in their writing and teaching ministry as a result.
Spiritual Growth Cannot Be Rushed
The problem is not the new technology or the introduction of more efficient ways of gathering needed material to rightly interpret a given passage. Rather, it is the possibility that these tools will circumvent the meditative process that is essential to biblical study and genuine spiritual growth. Above all, biblical study cannot be rushed because spiritual growth cannot be rushed.
Throughout the Bible, spiritual growth is depicted with agricultural metaphors (Ps 1:3; Matt 13:23; Luke 6:43; Rom 7:4; Gal 5:22-23). This is no accident. Yielding fruit simply takes time, and the process cannot be hurried. We must plant, water, pray, and wait.
Spiritual growth is the same. We may be able to gather a massive amount of information about a passage at the click of a button and use an A.I. model to summarize, collate, and organize the material in a particular way. But none of this will become spiritually beneficial until we start carefully and prayerfully meditating on the material we have accessed.
But even so, the sheer ease with which we can access information may hinder the meditative process because it has introduced an element into our exegetical method that is detrimental to spiritual growth: speed. It could be that, while inefficient, the gathering of that knowledge through a slower process may be more conducive to mental clarity, keener insights, warmer affections, and sharper convictions about what a passage is really teaching.
Losing Our Ability to Think Well
The concern that I have over A.I. is not only with Bible teachers and preachers using it for content creation (a practice I downright deplore), but how this practice and other pre- and post-writing uses (ideation, discussion, research summarization, editing) will undermine the process of thinking and meditation that is essential for genuine spiritual progress and authentic, Spirit-empowered preaching.
I believe that a man who relies on A.I. for content creation as well as for his pre- and post-writing needs will slowly find himself unable to think well without the help of these tools. This inability to think well without the aid of A.I. will eventually show up in places where he can’t access these resources.
Obviously, the preaching itself will lack Spiritual power because the content was not created through the painstaking, Spirit-dependent process of interpretation and homiletical development. Over time, people who sit under A.I.-generated teaching will languish spiritually, even if the material is “biblical.” Why? Because it will not have been crafted nor delivered through the process required by the Holy Spirit himself. A. I. sermons will not stand the test of time.
But a man who lives off of A.I. for his ministry will also eventually find himself lacking biblical clarity and skill in the counseling office, during the Q & A times, in casual conversation with church members, and in his evangelistic encounters because he depends upon this technology to think for him.
Quality Over Quantity
There is no necessary virtue in producing a lot of spoken or written material. Excellence of insight, depth of thought, and growth in our ability to think well should be our goal, not lifetime word counts. Quality over quantity should be the aim of every Bible teacher, pastor, and theologian. If you are tempted by A. I. to tilt toward the latter at the expense of the former, you can be sure that you are in danger of misusing this technology.
Let’s renew our efforts to follow the biblical model: meditation upon the Word of God, day and night (Ps 1:1-3), careful thinking over biblical truth (2 Tim 2:7), diligent seeking for and crying out to God for wisdom that comes from his mouth (Prov 2:1-8), and patient lingering over the Word of God until we see what is really there (Ps 119). In other words, let’s pursue a life of slow exegesis.
